Last refreshed on 28.10.2025 19:03:41
 
Commentary
Commentary
The Christian Science Monitor | Commentary - 2025-10-22 19:36:42 - the Monitor's Editorial Board

Depolarizing America, the local way

 

More than three weeks into the federal government shutdown, Democratic and Republican leaders still refuse to talk to each other about how to end it. That impasse is reflected in a recent poll that found 2 out of 3 Americans do not trust the U.S. political system to solve the country’s divisions.

Despite that popular view, many people are still finding ways to work together, exercising local agency to address pressing community issues. One example is the case of Three Rivers, Michigan, where Monitor staff writer Scott Baldauf found that shared concerns over contaminated water are helping dissolve partisan distrust. Similar “kitchen-table pragmatism,” as one source described it, is evident through much of small-town and rural America. Now, several mainstream philanthropies are supporting such efforts with the hope of creating new civic models.

Formed last year, the Trust for Civic Life charity has already awarded $17 million to 150 programs in rural communities and recently announced more grants. “We have to be in the communities that are polarizing ... to support them to understand what’s happening and how they can be successful,” Executive Director Charlie Brown told the site Inside Philanthropy.

At the state level, others are working to bridge urban and rural divides, which mirror the growing partisan gap, even though most Americans share similar priorities on the economy, education, and health care. Even the environment is a mutual concern, but rural residents and farmers believe their economic concerns are disregarded by activists.

Each year, Kentucky’s Rural-Urban Exchange brings together about 60 residents to cultivate common ground. Such “social infrastructure creates infrastructure for anything to happen,” co-founder Savannah Barrett told The New York Times. “But conversation can’t be about conversion,” she cautioned.

For the American Exchange Project, it’s about preventing polarization before it becomes entrenched, by arranging youth “exchange visits” across the United States. The project’s co-founder, David McCullough III, calls this “experiential civics.”

Deepen your worldview

with Monitor Highlights.

Already a subscriber? Log in to hide ads.

Most high schoolers have “not run into people who are different enough from them,” Mr. McCullough wrote this week on the website The 74. As a result, the “muscles that help them navigate nuance ... and connect with people who might disagree with them are unexercised.” Since 2019, some 1,500 students have joined in more than 200 exchanges – venturing from Silicon Valley to Kansas to the East Coast.

Ultimately, joint action in local settings helps build “feelings of agency, social trust, and belonging,” a study by the Trust for Civic Life confirmed. Working on shared priorities – rather than talking politics – is “the best reference point. Community opens the door, but politics can close it.”

commentary
The Christian Science Monitor | Commentary