Last refreshed on 04.07.2026 21:08:33
 
Culture
Culture
The Christian Science Monitor | The Culture - 2026-07-01 17:35:41 - Barbara Spindel

The American Revolution in 5 books: Triumph and tragedy

 

As Americans commemorate the nation’s semiquincentennial on July 4, history buffs have much to celebrate. Recent months have seen the publication of dozens of new books on the Revolutionary era, pegged to the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. The five we spotlight here are compelling chronicles of the past, and, as most edifying histories do, they illuminate our current moment as well.

A terrific book for readers seeking an exhaustive account of the nation’s founding is “The American Revolution: An Intimate History,” the companion text to documentarian Ken Burns’ six-part PBS series. Co-written by Burns and his frequent collaborator Geoffrey C. Ward, the volume presents the war in its multiple dimensions. It was “a bloody struggle that would engage more than two dozen nations, European as well as Native American,” the authors write, “that also somehow came to be about the noblest aspirations of humankind.”

Ward and Burns highlight the fact that the Revolution deeply divided the colonists, with as many as one-fifth remaining loyal to the crown. Indigenous nations were also divided, but many aligned with the British in the hopes of blocking the colonists’ westward expansion. Finally, some enslaved people sought freedom by siding with the Patriots, while others were promised emancipation by the British forces.

Why We Wrote This

In 1776, the 13 colonies declared independence from Britain. The underdog colonists defeated a major military power and lit the beacon of liberty for people around the world. Still, the American Revolution “was as much an idea as an event,” writes one historian, and thus has no natural end point. America is a work in progress. A group of recent books delves deeply into the era’s successes and challenges.

The massive book covers the conflict’s roots, its Enlightenment underpinnings, its extreme brutality, and its global repercussions. Six stand-alone essays by historians, including Maya Jasanoff, Vincent Brown, and Philip J. Deloria, add scholarly heft. Finally, “The American Revolution” is sumptuously illustrated with hundreds of paintings, maps, and photographs of museum artifacts, making it a visual feast not unlike, say, a Ken Burns documentary.

July 4, 2026, marks not only the 250th anniversary of the declaration’s signing, but also the 200th anniversary of the deaths of two of America’s founders: Thomas Jefferson and John Adams. “A Perfect Coincidence” is Jim Rasenberger’s engaging dual biography of Jefferson and Adams, covering their individual accomplishments as well as their complex relationship, which spanned friendship, rivalry, estrangement, and, finally, reconciliation.

The readable narrative explores the men’s virtues and flaws and captures their contrasting personalities. Of the Southern aristocrat Jefferson – author of the declaration and enslaver, over his lifetime, of approximately 600 people – Rasenberger writes, “No American was ever more idealistic than Jefferson, and no American more at war with his own ideals.” Meanwhile, the vain, combative Adams, an ardent revolutionary and the nation’s first vice president and second president, “never met a high sentiment he did not question.”

Rasenberger gives the near-simultaneous 1826 deaths of Jefferson and Adams fascinating context, demonstrating that in its time, the astonishing coincidence was seen as miraculous evidence of America’s divine favor. Until then, “it had been mainly a matter of faith and interpretation that Divine Providence took a special interest in the United States,” the author writes. “Here now was incontrovertible proof.” The sign was welcomed by a populace seeking reassurance as fierce arguments over slavery strained the bonds of union.

Of course, one could fill a library with biographies of the Founding Fathers. Other worthy new ones include H.W. Brands’ life of George Washington, “American Patriarch,” and Jack Kelly’s “Tom Paine’s War,” about the author of the galvanizing 1776 pamphlet “Common Sense” (whom Rasenberger dubs “an honorary Founder”). Two excellent recent biographies set during the Revolution spotlight little-known figures whose lives provide important insight into the era.

“Hamilton” fans might quibble with the characterization of the Schuyler sisters as “little-known.” They feature prominently in Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Broadway musical: Its subject, Alexander Hamilton, the first treasury secretary, was married to Eliza Schuyler and had an intense attachment to her sister, Angelica. Amanda Vaill’s vivid, elegant “Pride and Pleasure,” winner of the Pulitzer Prize in biography, gives the story of the formidable sisters epic sweep.

The family patriarch, Philip Schuyler, was a major general in the Continental Army and later a U.S. senator; their elite background afforded the sisters access to early America’s key figures, even if their own power derived from their proximity to powerful men. The author elucidates Angelica’s desire to be, in Vaill’s words, “an actor in the drama taking place around her, not a passive observer.” She charts how Eliza, more understated than her sister, aided Hamilton in his work and then acted to preserve his legacy after his 1804 death. Vaill notes that women like the Schuyler sisters are often eclipsed by men; after all, they “signed no declarations, negotiated no treaties, enacted no laws.” Her deeply researched – and deeply enjoyable – account of the women’s lives makes our understanding of the period fuller and richer.

David George’s life was as eventful as that of any celebrated figure of the Revolutionary era. As Gregory E. O’Malley’s “The Escapes of David George” documents, George was born enslaved on a Virginia tobacco plantation in 1742. At age 19, he escaped his brutal enslaver and fled to the Carolina backcountry. (At a time when there were no free states, the author points out that George had no obvious destination to run to.) He was held captive in Creek and Natchez communities before being sold by his Indigenous captors to a fur trader, leading to a decade of re-enslavement on a South Carolina plantation. During those years, George converted to Christianity and started what is likely the world’s first Black Baptist church.

During the Revolution, the British promised emancipation to slaves fleeing “rebel” masters. George organized a mass escape to British lines, fleeing with 50 men, women, and children. At the end of the war, he relocated with white Loyalists and other newly emancipated Black people to Nova Scotia. In 1792, he moved with his family a final time to Britain’s experimental antislavery colony in Sierra Leone. In addition to being an extraordinary story, the book highlights what O’Malley calls a “bitter irony”: that “rights to ‘Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness’ describe perfectly what David George and thousands of other Black refugees pursued by fleeing the American Revolution rather than joining it.”

O’Malley notes that throughout American history, men and women have fought for equality, writing that “in modern conflicts over voting rights, racialized incarceration rates, and pathways to citizens for immigrants, ... struggles over inclusion and exclusion in American democracy continue.” Those who wish to ponder these struggles on July 4 will be participating in a distinguished tradition. In “The Long Revolution,” Nathan Perl-Rosenthal explains that before it became associated with fireworks and barbecues, the Fourth was a day for contemplating the national experiment in self-government. For the first century after the Revolutionary War, the holiday had as its centerpiece a public oration assessing the health of the country’s founding principles.

Deepen your worldview

with Monitor Highlights.

Already a subscriber? Log in to hide ads.

Using 2,500 surviving speeches as source material, Perl-Rosenthal demonstrates that early generations of Americans viewed the Revolution as fragile and incomplete. Earlier speeches tended to focus on external threats to the republic, such as those that culminated in the War of 1812. Afterward, the orations turned to internal divisions, particularly those related to slavery. He cites abolitionist Frederick Douglass’ 1852 address as a masterpiece of the form, with Douglass insisting, in the author’s words, that “the work of the Revolution was not done so long as slavery survived.”

In 2026, official celebrations have taken a triumphalist approach to America’s founding. There is no shortage of triumph in these books: The colonists overcame a superior military power to prevail in a war fought in the name of universal human liberty. But there’s also tragedy, not least in the nation’s failure to live up to its exalted ideals. In Perl-Rosenthal’s view, the American Revolution “was as much an idea as an event,” and as such, it “has no natural ending point” until its goals have been fulfilled for all. Two hundred fifty years on, the quest for “a more perfect union” continues.

culture
The Christian Science Monitor | The Culture